The Traffic Accident Reconstruction Origin -ARnews-


Re: Who gets the PCF on this collision??

Brian P. Griffin (not.paid.enough@all)
Thu, 11 Feb 1999 10:00:05 -0500 (EST)

For those not familiar with California law enforcement jargon: PCF stands for
"Primary Collision Factor" i.e. the statutory violation held to be the
principal factor responsible for the collision. Unfortunately, the report
form fails to recognize that accidents can (and usually do) have more than
one equally necessary contributing factor. Remember that it's only an opinion,
but it's YOUR opinion--so make sure it reflects YOUR honest view of the
crash, based on the available facts coupled with sound (and defensible) reasoning.
Don't decide based on poll results.

>Several officers, including myself, have used the argument that D-2 had a
>reasonable expectation that D-1 would not commit the violations she did and
>had complied with the requirements of CVC21802(a).

Just to throw something else in the stew: If you believe (as you seem to indicate)
that D-2 behaved reasonably and prudently, then once she entered the
intersection SHE had the right-of-way, and D-1 should have yielded to HER
per CVC 21802(b).

>We’ve all used this
>”reasonable expectation” argument before but I have yet to see it in writing
>somewhere. Anyone know if it might be in the Vehicle Code somewhere?

Don't know of anything statutory, but there are standard jury instructions to
the effect that one has the right to assume lawful bahavior on the part of others.
Check BAJI or CALJIC.
Brian P. Griffin
not.paid.enough@all


NOTE: You are reading in an archived session of ARnews. It is possible that this topic is still being discussed. To see if this topic is still active, or of there were any more recent posts on this topic, check later archives of ARnews.

If there is no current post, and you would like to add to this topic, link to the Current ARnews Discussion and begin a new thread. Be sure that if you are starting a new post that the thread title does not contain the abbreviation RE: Placing RE: at the beginning of a new post will confuse Hypermail and prevent others from answering your post in the future.

For example, to continue this discussion look for a thread titled

Who gets the PCF on this collision??

If this thread does not exist in the current archive, you can begin another one by using that title.


451.html">robert sebastian Mon, 11 Aug 2003 08:22:33 -0600 (MDT)
  • 1996 International Truck
  • 1998 Honda CBR 900
  • 2000 GMC Jimmy rollovers and fires
  • 2001 ACTAR Examination Dates
  • 3-D Animation Software suggestions needed
  • 3566
  • 3rd Edition released
  • 4 WHEELER LOW SPEED FLIP END OVER END
  • 69 Ford Mustang Gas Tank
  • =?windows-1252?Q?Invitaci=F3n_2do._Congreso_Internacional_de_Capacitaci=F3n_Virtual?=
  • A and B Stiffness Coefficients
  • a huose dvidied aagnist istelf cnanot satnd
  • A SkateBoard Must! TailViper
  • A/R Book
  • abroad
  • ABS Brakes
  • ABS stopping distance
  • acceleration
  • Acceleration data for 1998 Ford Explorer 4x4
  • Acceleration Prior to Braking
  • Acceleration Rate
  • Acceleration rates on grade
  • Accident caused by footboard mount
  • Accident Investigation/Reconstruction and AutoCAD Presentation
  • Accident investigator status
  • Accident Reconstruction Expert Certification for PA Courts
  • Accident Reconstruction Software
  • Account Over Due
  • ACTAR Board Meeting
  • ACTAR EXAM
  • Advice on entering the Accident Reconstruction field
  • Air Bag Deployment Failure
  • Air bag deployment in rear end crash
  • air bag identification
  • Air Bag, Frontal Pole Impact
  • Air bag, late deployment
  • Air bag, non deployment
  • Airbag cars SDM recorders
  • Airbag Chemicals
  • Airbag Deployment Death
  • Airbag injuries
  • Airbag injuries,Dangers
  • Airbags
  • AIRBORN PEDESTRIANS
  • Airborne Formulae
  • Aircraft Crash Investigation Training
  • Ambien, Lipitor, Nexium, Paxil, Phentermine, Viagra, Vioxx, Xanax - Limited Time
  • Ambien, Lipitor, Nexium, Paxil, Phentermine, Viagra, Vioxx, Xanax and more Prescribed ...
  • amputation railroad incident
  • An invitation has been sent to you.
  • Anatomical averages
  • Angles from photo
  • Animation Software
  • annoyance
  • Anti-freeze on front tires-can tire marks be made on centerline?
  • antonio lope
  • Any way to stop all this SPAM on this site
  • Anyone teaching grade crossing crash investigation?
  • Appropriate parameters for roll/stability model
  • AR electronic book now available
  • AR Requirements
  • Are there accident simulation programs?
  • ARnews Frequently Asked Questions
  • arnews@tarorigin.com - RE: refinance-now even with bad-credit
  • Automobile Bumper Specs
  • Automotive Black Boxes
  • Autosketch Version 6
  • average averred
  • Award for Recognization Submissions
  • Backhoe accidents on public thoroughfares/auto involved and serious head injury to young boy pas
  • Backhoe accidents on public thoroughfares/auto involved and serious head injury to young boy passeng
  • BARZELEY and LACEY EQUATION
  • Beam Pattern Data
  • BERZELEY and LACEY EQUATION
  • Best rates- as low as 2.95%
  • bicycle acceleration rate
  • Bicycle Drag Factor
  • Bicyclist thrown after impact
  • Big Profits on Foreclosed Properties
  • biodegradable solution to lower friction on skidpad
  • Black Box Data on 1997 GM Pickup Truck
  • Black Box Research Paper